To Dave, With Love

123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839
Across
  1. 3. The site of a future redemption
  2. 8. 1/2 of this great swirl
  3. 9. What caused the incident in the longest answer on this puzzle
  4. 13. A bagel topping before by the subjects of this puzzle
  5. 15. A favorite dig for the author of this puzzle
  6. 18. The author of the book Jailyn is watching you read as she makes this
  7. 20. A perfect specimen to one of the topics of this puzzle
  8. 23. You showed me this Southern city during our last baecation
  9. 25. "Where are all the hot people? I was told that there would be all these attractive singles."
  10. 27. A little bass
  11. 28. The last place we went out before quarantine
  12. 30. Miss Parnell lived here
  13. 31. $12 a year, a steal I'd say
  14. 32. Pepperidge Farm's Biggest Fan
  15. 33. Summer Destination
  16. 38. The inspiration for this gift
  17. 39. Dave & Chet Hanks
Down
  1. 1. Siri will play this if you ask
  2. 2. A perfect specimen
  3. 3. Red Dead Redemption, a leather bag, and these
  4. 4. It happens to the best of us (but only one person in this relationship)
  5. 5. The street Dave lived on when you we met
  6. 6. Jailyn's favorite meal of the day
  7. 7. A favorite spot for this couple
  8. 10. My biggest competition
  9. 11. The author of the first book suggestion you gave Jailyn that she actually read
  10. 12. The month that we first said I love you
  11. 14. When you finally got some sense
  12. 16. A prominent feature of heaven
  13. 17. The street Jailyn lived on when we met
  14. 19. A prominent animal in a bar visited during our last baecation
  15. 21. A small school in Boston
  16. 22. A sequel that people with great taste would say is better than the original
  17. 24. A dream
  18. 26. Heaven
  19. 29. 1/2 of this great swirl
  20. 34. Jailyn will often order one of these, but then she'll like your's better
  21. 35. Mexican Heaven
  22. 36. Jailyn didn't know how to play this game until you showed her during quarantine
  23. 37. Valentine's Day 2020 Gift