What a Lucky Guy: In honor of William's hard earned victory in capturing Melissa's heart

2. His and Melissa were always good at making people laugh but he made her cry at prom and it didn't work out
3. He grew up with 5 sisters but apparently didn't know enough about women to keep Melissa around
6. He escorted Melissa to her freshman homecoming dance
8. He and Melissa dated briefly in high school before her longer stint with Phil
10. Melissa briefly dated both of these public school lads during her rebellious days
14. Melissa secretly went to the movies with him before getting permission from Mama Jean. Bridesmaid Danielle covered for her.
15. He took Melissa to her first high school dance
16. Melissa and he loved double dating with bridesmaid Katie and her now husband groomsman Steven
17. A mid-summer fling who years later tried to date sister of the bride and maid of honor Anna
18. Melissa was dating him when she and Will first met at Kent State University
19. Melissa went to one dance with him and later dated his friend Joe

1. THE ONE!
4. He was Prince Charming at Disney World but couldn't make Melissa into his Cinderella
5. Melissa was quite dissatisfied with her hairstyle for her homecoming date with him but her outfit was cool enough to make up for it and he brought her a spider mum
7. He and Melissa performed a swing dance together in one of her dance recitals and sparks flew, but soon fizzled.
9. He asked Melissa to her first prom
11. His grandparents were Melissa's childhood neighbors which allowed for one summer romance filled with bike rides and trips to the Midvale Speedway
12. Melissa danced with his sister for years before he took her on a few dates and gave her a "really awesome kiss"
13. He was the waterboy for the football team and Melissa's 7th grade crush
18. Will could not believe Melissa moved on so quickly to this hockey player before he had the chance to ask her out