Across
- 3. It's almost better than a glass of wine
- 5. "____, ____, ____, ____ good!"
- 6. Sarah's favorite hormone
- 8. Homemade, wheat-based, and delicious
- 9. Sarah's German penpal
- 14. Sarah's preferred first date appetizer
- 17. First street Sarah and Nick lived on together
- 19. Favorite Port Jefferson dining spot (casual)
- 20. Nick's preferred style of beer
- 22. Site of Sarah and Nick's wedding
- 23. They make the best viognier on Long Island
- 26. Nick's favorite republic
- 27. "Isn't this supposed to be a comedy??", TV show
- 28. Nick rode in an elevator with him
- 30. Nick's favorite gourd
- 32. Favorite Port Jefferson dining spot (fancy)
- 33. Sarah and Nick's favorite and only roadside food option
- 35. Jeweler where Sarah and Nick bought their wedding rings
- 37. Matchmaker
- 38. Wedding anniversary month
- 40. first dance song, artist
Down
- 1. "Rotund message," at the vet
- 2. Serious contender for last name
- 4. third city Nick and Sarah lived in together
- 7. He gets the blues
- 8. Dating anniversary month
- 10. The miraculous one
- 11. Maureen's husbands favorite drink, in duplicate
- 12. Favorite Chicago dining spot (casual)
- 13. Actual name of Nick's favorite gourd
- 15. One way to get free Mets tickets
- 16. Text on Nick's most punny t-shirt
- 18. 59-cent lunch
- 21. a big adventurer
- 24. Germany's Next Top Model host
- 25. Columbus' favorite bartender
- 29. The little one
- 31. The best kind of joke
- 34. One-time backyard infestation
- 36. Sarah’s favorite meal that Nick thinks they make too much, ____ curry
- 39. Nick’s favorite meal to eat when Sarah is out of town, _______ burrito
