New York City

4. Our favorite place to take in a game (2)
5. We visited the _____________ Museum of Art - one of our favorites
6. I eat bags of this at Christmastime, courtesy of the Bryant Park Fair
9. We've seen this band several times - but never in the city
10. You visited me here during the summer of 2010
12. Bagels and iced coffee from this Grand Central institution are a morning necessity
13. We endured dinner with TJ at this West Side sports bar
15. I worked here with some holier-than-thou, entitled 20-somethings
16. You love their overpriced soups, for whatever reason (3)
18. We finally saw this bewitching musical on Broadway
19. We saw the Christmas Spectacular at this venue and left in tears (2)
20. I always insist on swinging by the _________ World Store
22. We saw the season premiere of this opera at the Met (2)
24. The type of museum featuring unflinching, meltable celebrities

1. You handled this while at SMEG; UPS loves it, you didn't
2. We always have to stop at this store by Grand Central
3. We saw this musical with Ferris Bueller in the cast and two loud ladies sitting behind us (7)
7. Where we spent dinner on Valentine's Day 2013 (2)
8. You always have to stop at Chocolate by the _____ ___ (2)
11. This club held a swingin' Christmas surprise - and a White Christmas singalong, too!
14. Our yearly tradition is to visit our inflatable friends from the ______ this holiday parade
17. Old lady Bastianich's Italian restaurant
19. We saw this soccer team as a group - finally (2)
21. The second-worst gelateria in the world - it's a chain
23. This superstore houses "i bibanesi" and takes us back to our other life