Across
- 3. Rory's true love
- 5. -the-Pooh
- 7. The prince of demons in Abrahamic religions
- 9. First movie we watched together
- 10. You like their shrimp salad
- 12. Your fourth guess on my Hogwarts house
- 14. The Beatles said it's all you need
- 15. Protagonist in Gremlins movie franchise
- 16. A grayish-beige color flecked with brown
- 18. Two of these means it's time to kiss
- 21. Comedian we saw for our 1st anniversary
- 23. Where we had our first kiss
- 24. Band we have seen live twice
- 25. First band you recommended me
- 27. What we ate on our first date
- 28. The first book you "lent" me
Down
- 1. What we make on Valentine's Day
- 2. Buffy's BFF
- 4. Word following the highlighted answers
- 6. Marvel's coolest mutant
- 7. Andrews of Riverdale
- 8. Daily word puzzle x16
- 11. Month we met
- 13. Composer of the first play we saw together
- 14. Lyrics from this song were on the first card I made you
- 17. Band who wrote "Whistle for the Choir"
- 19. Our first couples costume
- 20. Actress Williams who starred in 8 seasons of Game of Thrones
- 22. Best place for chicken tenders
- 26. Muppet who sings "I'm Going To Go Back There Someday"