Across
- 7. Beach pizza parlor
- 9. Restaurant where you are served food raw
- 10. When Penny saved Brady
- 12. How far I love Penny to, according to Neil
- 14. "IT" author, one of Penny's favorites
- 15. Pre Iberia dinner
- 16. Cohen secondary NFL allegiance
- 17. Title for an auto
- 18. Big purchase if Penny won the lottery
- 20. "From Eden" artist
- 21. Christmas village dinner
- 23. Penny's top ranked kiss locale
- 26. Common babysitee between us
- 28. Club, not a government agency
- 29. Where Penny is Capt.
- 33. Bug capital of the word, according to Penny
- 35. The level Penny's team made it to for 54-Down
- 37. Found in Jackson's room, only used by Penny
- 38. Corn Linvilla eats
- 40. Purple with blue undertones, not pink ones
- 43. Post formal eats
- 44. Hoco dress hue
- 45. What Penny looks like while hydrating
- 47. Initial "I love you" venue
- 50. Sutton Terrace job
- 52. Teacher when we met
- 53. Best college essay workplace, just ask Penny
- 55. How Penny makes me feel, per Sinatra
- 56. Place to paint middle names
- 57. Sense used in many gifts for each other
Down
- 1. Eatery to "learn" physics?
- 2. Mary who was only in Philadelphia for 5 months
- 3. Sour orange fruit, to a Parisian
- 4. Cardiovascular Extracurricular
- 5. "Version" of Penny's Judaism
- 6. Town in which Penny is a local, pretty much
- 7. "I like that plan"
- 8. Hoagie spot where a half is enough
- 11. 0th year spot
- 13. Amt. of milk Penny likes in her coffee
- 19. Date spot before they were dates
- 22. Penny's music choice, on some days
- 24. Type of 37-Across
- 25. "Barcelona" dish
- 27. Wild card game opponent
- 30. "Genre" of a Penny playlist
- 31. Job where you see many of your job title
- 32. Sacred thing, as specified by "Thee"
- 34. Wine bottle animal
- 36. Football coach, or one founder of a spot of get affogatos
- 39. Protein for a Penny Hoagie, typically
- 41. Where to find Penny's gum
- 42. Unofficial name for a preferred ice cream flavor available at WFC
- 46. New food tried on the 17th
- 48. Lego, or the Fighting Irish
- 49. Holiday flower makeup?
- 51. New-ish sport for Penny
- 54. Sport where the main event could be found in a glass box
