Across
- 3. Honorary 5th member
- 5. A.K.A. Edu
- 7. Blue tie
- 8. Debut album, 4th word in title
- 9. Tally Hall's Internet Show (Abbreviation)
- 13. Red tie
- 15. "Do you hear the flibbity jibbity jibber jabber"
- 17. Debut album, 2nd word in title
- 18. Actual Cannibal
- 20. Debut album, 1st word in title
Down
- 1. Currently works for Disney
- 2. "Don't you like it? I know I do"
- 4. "But the wound that she leaves in unmistakable"
- 6. Not a _____
- 10. "Worst of all, it knows its only truth is made of lies"
- 11. First song of first album
- 12. Debut album, 3rd word in title
- 14. Tally Hall's 2nd album
- 16. Just a drummer
- 19. Tally Hall's Largest Fansite (Abbreviation, named after a song)