Across
- 2. His and Melissa were always good at making people laugh but he made her cry at prom and it didn't work out
- 3. He grew up with 5 sisters but apparently didn't know enough about women to keep Melissa around
- 6. He escorted Melissa to her freshman homecoming dance
- 8. He and Melissa dated briefly in high school before her longer stint with Phil
- 10. Melissa briefly dated both of these public school lads during her rebellious days
- 14. Melissa secretly went to the movies with him before getting permission from Mama Jean. Bridesmaid Danielle covered for her.
- 15. He took Melissa to her first high school dance
- 16. Melissa and he loved double dating with bridesmaid Katie and her now husband groomsman Steven
- 17. A mid-summer fling who years later tried to date sister of the bride and maid of honor Anna
- 18. Melissa was dating him when she and Will first met at Kent State University
- 19. Melissa went to one dance with him and later dated his friend Joe
Down
- 1. THE ONE!
- 4. He was Prince Charming at Disney World but couldn't make Melissa into his Cinderella
- 5. Melissa was quite dissatisfied with her hairstyle for her homecoming date with him but her outfit was cool enough to make up for it and he brought her a spider mum
- 7. He and Melissa performed a swing dance together in one of her dance recitals and sparks flew, but soon fizzled.
- 9. He asked Melissa to her first prom
- 11. His grandparents were Melissa's childhood neighbors which allowed for one summer romance filled with bike rides and trips to the Midvale Speedway
- 12. Melissa danced with his sister for years before he took her on a few dates and gave her a "really awesome kiss"
- 13. He was the waterboy for the football team and Melissa's 7th grade crush
- 18. Will could not believe Melissa moved on so quickly to this hockey player before he had the chance to ask her out